I recently returned from teaching a fine class of Doctor of Ministry students (Preaching the Literary Forms of the Bible track) at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary. It’s always enjoyable and a privilege each May to join my good friend, Dr. Jeffrey Arthurs, for these days.
However, one of our responsibilities is listening to their sermons. My mentor, Dr. Haddon Robinson, once said that he had listened to so many bad sermons over the years, it’s a wonder he was still a Christian. He was half-joking. Thankfully, these students preached well.
But here’s what I observed from listening to nine of ten sermons in one day (All the sermons were dealing with preaching a narrative text.):
We have a tendency to spend too much time retelling the history of the text and not enough time telling the theology of the text.
If I remember correctly, I wrote that comment on virtually every sermon evaluation form.
It seems that instinctively (or due to training/modeling) we believe our task as preachers is to rehearse past redemptive history. Preachers keep their listeners in the past, learning about what happened in the Story.
WE’RE THEOLOGIANS, NOT HISTORIANS
I encouraged the class to think of themselves as theologians, not historians. That means, of course, that we’re able to write the sermon from the perspective of conveying theology, not history. That means we know how each part of the Story is functioning for the Church. That means we know how each part of the Story addresses our human condition as churchgoers. That means we are always talking to us about us from God’s Word. It’s never about God’s Word.
Next time you preach try to monitor yourself in the moment–are you sounding like a history lecture or a theologian/pastor?
And may our Lord receive glory in the church and in Christ Jesus (Ephesians 3:21).
Randal